Eyeliner Vs Eye Pencil

Eye pencils isolated on a white background

There is a good trick to applying eyeliner when you lack confidence or experience. The best way to keep the line straight and not mess up is to draw little dashes first. Then once you are done, you can connect those dashes and create a very straight line.

What is Eyeliner?

An eyeliner applicator with a brush tip isolated on a white background

Eyeliner is a make-up beauty product that helps you enhance the look of your eyes and lashes. You only apply it to your eyelids or underneath your eye but the right touch makes sure your lashes are not excluded from your overall look.

This is a liquid option that takes a steady hand to apply correctly but once applied your eyes should pop. Usually, this type of eyeliner goes on by a brush but there are some types that now incorporate the use of a marker.

This style keeps the benefits of the liquid without the risk of making a mess.

What is an Eye Pencil?

An eye pencil with shavings on a white background

This is the easy way of applying eyeliner. You just need to sharpen the pencil and then apply the contents carefully around your eyes. The key is not to make the point too sharp unless you want really fine lines.

There is no mess or fuss with this eyeliner option. Plus, you can smudge it a bit to give your eyes that great smokey look you like. Then you can choose from multiple colors to get that creative look you always wanted.

Dressing up your eyes is a lot easier when you use the right tools.

How are they Different?

Close up of eyeliner being applied.

The difference is obvious. The eyeliner is a liquid or can be found in a special marker that applies the liquid easily. Usually, the liquid is found in a bottle and you need a nice fine brush to apply it.

An eye pencil is a hard form that just needs you to draw on your eyelid and you have the shade that you want. Its solid form makes it hard to make a mistake and you can always use the smudges to create a unique look.

The eyeliner, you need to wait for it to dry before you go out or add new make-up. With the pencil, it dries very quickly, and you do not have to wait for it. At least that long.

How are they Similar?

teal colored eye pencil being applied

There are a lot of similarities between these two products. The first is that they both apply to the same area of your eyelids and under your eyes.

The second is that they come in multiple colors so that you can match your eyeliner with the color of your eye shadow.

Then you can use both products to help enhance the look of your eyelashes without placing any liner on them. Also, you can create cat’s eyes and other decorative features that will make your eyes look larger than they really are.

In addition to that, this product is not for every occasion and should be used at the right time if one is really going to make an entrance.

What’s Better About Eyeliner?

liquid eyeliner being applied to a top eye lid

There is not much that is better in this product than the eye pencil. You get the same type of colors, the same creative designs, and the same look. If anything that makes eyeliner better is that the brush allows you to see what you are doing better.

One aspect that may make this product superior is that it may last longer than the eye pencil. It comes in waterproof colors and applications allowing you to wear it all day without worry.

What’s Better About Eye Pencil?

Full face view of a woman applying eye pencil

One of the aspects that make this product better than eyeliner is that you do not have to worry about making a mess. If you make a mistake, you can wipe it off easily or rub it a little to change a bad line into a nice smokey effect.

Also, you do not have to worry about spilling anything if you drop it. The pencil does not get liquid all over the place like the brush will when it is dropped. Then the cost of this product is very low. You can buy many of these pencils and have one in every color for the price of one liquid eyeliner.

Who Should Get Eyeliner?

Close up of eyes wearing makeup

This is not a product for young girls. If they are beginners at applying makeup they should not use this product until they have practiced for a few years. Then, this product is more for the older women who have practiced and want to branch out in their make-up look.

They want a nice alluring look that will bring the men’s attention to their eyes no matter where they are in the room.

Who Should Get Eye Pencil?

Full face view of a woman applying makeup

This product is for beginners. It is cheap, effective, and very easy to put on. One can practice the art of applying eyeliner with a pencil. The beginner can build up their confidence, experiment with different looks before graduating to the liquid eyeliner.

Quick Comparison chart


                EyelinerEye Pencil


  Takes some practice

  No experience necessary


  Too many to list here

  Too many to list here



  Dry solid

  Ease of use

  There is some risk of spillage or dropping the brush

  Very easy to use and mistakes are easy to correct





  Very expensive  Very inexpensive

Woman having Kajal applied to eyes

Eyeliner VS Kajal

Close up of a woman applying eyebrow pencil

Eyeliner Vs Eyebrow Pencil