What is the Best Eyeliner for Allergy Eyes?

Single, feminine eye that is red and irritated

No One is Perfect

This is the thing about this world, while people all strive to have the best-looking eyes and use the top of line products, some women are not able to. The reason for that issue is that their eyes are allergic to some of the ingredients involved in creating eyeliners.

There is some good news for those allergy sufferers. There are some great products made for them. The top make-up companies have produced hypoallergenic items that will keep your eyes looking their best without triggering your allergies.

Just continue to read our article to learn more about these products.

What to Look for When Buying this Product

Eyeliner pen leaning up against a wall with a squiggle on the floor

There are key aspects that should help guide your search for an eyeliner that works for you and your allergies. Here are a few of those characteristics to look for when you are in need of a hypoallergenic eyeliner:

1. Is it Really Hypoallergenic

This is the key question to answer before you make your purchase. Unfortunately, there is no perfect formula for this item. Different women and girls are allergic to different ingredients, and it is impossible to eliminate all the ingredients.

You just have to look at the ingredients to see if the product contains those chemicals, etc. your eyes are allergic to. To cut down the risk, you should look for an eyeliner that has more natural than synthetic ingredients inside.

Woman applying eyeliner against a white background

2. Ease of Use

While not a characteristic for hypoallergenic issues, you do not want to spend a lot of time in front of the mirror applying eyeliner. Find a product option that will be easy to apply and not cause any problem with clustering, build-up, and so on.

Pencils are generally the easiest option to use, and they come in a variety of colors so you can match your eye shadow and other make-up colors.

3. Lasts a Long Time

One of the key features of the best hypoallergenic eyeliner will be how long it will last. You do not want to continually be applying eyeliner all day. The build-up could damage your eyes or cause some irritation.

Instead, you want an eyeliner that will last all day and remove easily at night. Protecting your eyes is important, so find a version that will last all day and still keep your eyes looking fantastic.

Don’t Believe Everything You Read

Woman reading makeup lables

One of the problems with sorting out which eyeliner is hypoallergenic and which is not is that you are on your own. While a company may claim its product is safe for allergy sufferers, it may not be in reality.

While there is a wide variety of this version of eyeliner, not all of them will be telling you the truth. Sadly, you are on your own and may have to resort to trial and error to get the one that is right for your eyes and skin.

What follows are a few brands that will help your search for the perfect hypoallergenic eyeliner. They will come with their pros and cons so you can make a better decision when in the store:

1. La Pure Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp


  1. Truly hypoallergenic
  2. Easy to use
  3. Smudge-proof and water-resistant
  4. Long-lasting


  1. Only comes in black

2. Charlotte Tilbury Eye Liner – Walk of No Shame Collection


  1. Good texture, smudge-proof
  2. Gluten & cruelty-free
  3. Safe for your eye’s waterline


  1. Does not come in black

3. Physicians Formula Eye Booster


  1. Affordable
  2. Easy to use and customize
  3. Makes lashes more visible


  1. Is not waterproof
  2. May not last all-day

4. Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner


  1. Easy to apply
  2. Affordable and fits most budgets
  3. Waterproof formula


  1. Can smudge easily
  2. More chemicals than natural products

5. Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen Eyeliner


  1. Safe for sensitive eyes
  2. Precision tip for better application
  3. Long-lasting, up to 24 hours
  4. No synthetic fragrances or parabens


  1. Smudges very easily
  2. May need to apply several layers

6. Revlon Colorstay Skinny Liquid Eyeline


  1. Great Color Selection
  2. Long-Lasting After Application
  3. Skinny Tip for Easy Application


  1. Not waterproof
  2. May have too many chemical ingredients

Honorable Mention

L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner


  1. 16 hours of use
  2. Smudge-proof
  3. Provides protection
  4. Has a great shine to it


  1. Not waterproof

Some Final Words

Woman applying eyeliner to her top lid

Creating that perfect eye look when you have allergies to make-up chemicals can be difficult to accomplish. However, there are products on the market that will work with allergy sufferers and still make your eyes look great when you need them to look their best.

To find them, you may have to spend a little more time at the counter reading the labels.

Drops being applied to an eye

What is the Best Eyeliner for Dry Eyes?